Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
MLB: Former Cumberland Valley outfielder Beck Way drafted by New York Yankees in fourth round
breaking alert top story

MLB: Former Cumberland Valley outfielder Beck Way drafted by New York Yankees in fourth round

Baseball: State College at Cumberland Valley (copy) (copy)

Former Cumberland Valley baseball player Beck Way, who signed with the New York Yankees after being selected in the fourth round in June.

Cumberland Valley baseball coach Levi Mumma still vividly remembers Beck Way as a 4-year-old tyke trailing his grandfather around a baseball diamond.

Way was born into baseball and grew up in it.

And now he’s prospering.

The former outfielder and part-time pitcher for the Eagles who graduated high school in 2017, was picked in the fourth round (129th overall) by the New York Yankees. The signing bonus slot value for the 129th overall pick is $438,700.

It’s a proud moment for Mumma, and would be for Way’s grandfather, longtime CV fixture Michael “Whitey” Whitehead, who died at 64 years old in 2013.

“When Beck was born there weren’t many times that Beck wasn’t by his grandfather’s side,” Mumma said before the PIAA playoffs in 2016. “That blonde little kid running around the dugout, usually covered in dirt.”

PIAA Preview: Beck Way is making his grandfather proud in breakout season for Cumberland Valley

Way is no longer that little blonde kid. He’s a super athletic 6-foot-4, 200-pound baseball lifer with a 97-mile-per-hour fastball and incredible movement on his changeup and cutter.

He’s now steps away from being in the big leagues. It’s a destination Mumma is “absolutely” confident Way will reach one day.

Way is the highest draft pick from Cumberland Valley High School ever., according to

Way was drafted as a solid right-hander out of the junior college circuit, but the mound isn’t where he made his name. He mostly played outfield, only pitching as a closer and occasional starter for the Eagles.

As a junior, Way hit .350 with 18 RBIs and nine runs scored as CV marched to the PIAA Class 4A semifinals, the farthest an Eagles team had ever advanced in states. As a senior, Way accumulated 10 runs, 26 hits, 12 RBIs and a .342 batting average.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

He was known far more for his outfield prowess on a team that already had quality pitching in classmates Mitch Hoon and Adam Overcash. On the mound, Way went 1-2 with one save, 24 innings pitched, 29 strikeouts, a 1.46 ERA and a 1.67 WHIP.

“He threw hard [in high school], but when he was with me, he was 160 pounds soaking wet. He was skin and bones,” Mumma said before the second round began. “We had always said, always, ‘When this 18-year-old boy turns into a 20-something-year-old man, he’s gonna be something else.’”

Not until he hung around with kids in Cape Cod last summer.

“Once he got to Cape Cod and he saw those guys that had plans to become professional players, I think that sort of rubbed off on him,” Mumma said. “He just put on weight and he started working out.

“Once you get to the point where the rest of your competition is as good as you are, you’re going to find out how good you are.”

Way, who committed out of CV to Belmont Abbey College, spent his second and third years on the junior college circuit at Northwest Florida State College, where he pitched seven games and had a 0.67 ERA and 58 strikeouts. Before the pandemic-shortened 2020 season, he committed to Louisiana State University for the 2021 campaign.

He was listed as the top JUCO pitching prospect and seventh overall JUCO prospect by Baseball America.

Former Cumberland Valley baseball player Beck Way commits to LSU

To those close to Way, him being drafted isn’t a surprise.

“He’s the kid who grew up just being better than everyone else,” Mumma said. “I’m just proud that he continues to love the game for the game. That’s all it is to him is his favorite game to play. That’s all it is to him, a game.

“It’s not a job, it’s not a worry of his, he loves the game.”

Way will be the second Eagle currently in pro ball. Hunter Schryver is recovering from Tommy John surgery a few months ago and is in the Chicago White Sox system as a reliever. Before the injury, there was talk Schryver could reach the majors later in the year.

Pro baseball: Local grads in minors, independent leagues staying busy, optimistic as they await 2020 season's fate
MLB: Chicago White Sox prospect Hunter Schryver to undergo Tommy John surgery
A Timeout With... Former Cumberland Valley southpaw Hunter Schryver inches closer to potential major league call-up

Email Mallory Merda at or follow her on Twitter @MalloryMerda. Jake Adams contributed to this report.


Get in the game with our Prep Sports Newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News