Eagles' loss to the Dolphins was both a blessing and a curse for the Dallas Cowboys

Eagles' loss to the Dolphins was both a blessing and a curse for the Dallas Cowboys

DALLAS - When Dolphins punter Matt Haack threw a surprising touchdown pass to kicker Jason Sanders - part of Miami's stunning 37-31 comeback victory over the Eagles on Sunday - it was a blessing for the Cowboys and a curse for Jason Garrett.

Dallas is tied for the 14th-best record in the NFL and alone in first place in the NFC East. That rather preposterous set of circumstances is a result less of geography (does Dallas really belong in the East?) than convenience and prestige. The NFC East is the model division when it comes, historically, to fan support and interest. It just happens to be a wreck in 2019, which is why Philadelphia, playing its first of four games down the stretch against teams that were 2-9, failed to gain ground on the Cowboys on Sunday.

Can Dallas win the East with a 9-7 record? Actually, that is automatic as long as it beats Philadelphia. Can the Cowboys win it at 9-7 while losing to the Eagles? The answer again is yes as long as the Eagles stumble once more against the Giants or Redskins.

Dallas may even find itself hosting a 13-3 San Francisco or Seattle team with an 8-8 record. Such is its lack of competition this year. But does any of this foster belief in owner Jerry Jones' scenario in which fairy tales come true and Garrett leads this team to a Super Bowl?

That, for me, is how the Eagles' disgraceful defeat in Miami feels like a curse for Garrett and a signal that his time is up. The only chance for Dallas to regain its footing and put on a competitive show in the playoffs was to be stretched thin, to be forced to win the final four games of the regular season.

Beat Chicago in the cold Thursday night. Hold off the Rams, who appeared to rediscover some of last year's greatness Sunday even if it was against Arizona. Defeat the Eagles, of course, in Philadelphia, and then - don't rule out this final challenge - finish the season needing to beat the Redskins to reach 10-6. I can't think of anything that interim coach Bill Callahan would like to accomplish more than to defeat Garrett, his former uneasy supervisor during his one year of Cowboys play-calling, and end his run as a head coach in Dallas.

Instead, there's a reasonable chance the Cowboys can maintain their awkward lurch toward the finish line - lose again Thursday, or perhaps to the Rams - and arrive in Philadelphia with a 7-7 record and the division still theirs for the clinching with a win.

I don't see this team being handed such a gift, and then eliminating San Francisco, Seattle or Minnesota - potential first-round opponents in Arlington - and following that with victory on the road. These Cowboys have failed to beat a good team all year, and they're going to make a run against them when it counts?

This team may still capture the East, but it comes with a disclaimer. And it's one that presages a January playoff trip that feels anything but magical.

Visit The Dallas Morning News at www.dallasnews.com


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

When Andy Reid was an assistant coach at Northern Arizona in 1986, Dave Toub had recently joined Bob Stull's staff at Texas-El Paso and took Reid out for lunch as a prospective offensive-line coach. "Guess I must have said something good," Toub said, laughing, in a 2016 interview with The Star. "We hit it off, too, right away." From El Paso to Columbia, Missouri, to Philadelphia, they've ...

SANTA CLARA, Calif. - The 49ers on Thursday racked up another award from the Pro Football Writers of America. General manager John Lynch was named the association's executive of the year. Lynch became San Francisco's third general manager to claim the award joining Carmen Policy in 1994 and Trent Baalke in 2011. The 49ers this season became the sixth team since the AFL-NFL merger in 1970 to ...

Alonzo Highsmith won't be hired in an administrative role with the University of Miami football program, despite a brief second flirtation with the idea. Highsmith, a former Hurricanes legend and the Cleveland Browns' vice president of player personnel, was pushed by a handful of powerful Board of Trustees and football donors to accept a "Chief of Staff" role to help coach Manny Diaz and ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News