Ask/Answered: Softball coach from Carlisle awaiting sentencing for sexual assaults
top story

Ask/Answered: Softball coach from Carlisle awaiting sentencing for sexual assaults


Ask/Answered is a weekly feature for reader-submitted questions. Follow the blog online at

What’s happening with the criminal case against Joey Sullenberger, the softball coach accused of sexual assault?

The January arrest of a softball coach from Carlisle on charges of sexual assault shocked the community.

More details released about Carlisle softball coach charged with multiple sexual assaults
Carlisle area softball coach charged with sexual assault

Carlisle Police said that Joey Vincent Sullenberger, 49, of Carlisle, sexually assaulted at least four teenagers through his role as a private hitting coach at the former Central Penn Sportsplex. He provided one-on-one lessons with teenagers that on average lasted one hour.

What’s happened since the charges against Sullenberger were announced? Well, most importantly, he pleaded “no contest” on Aug. 28 to felony aggravated indecent assault, five counts of felony sexual assault by a sports official, and misdemeanor indecent assault, according to court documents. Fifteen other charges were dismissed.

Sentencing had been scheduled for Nov. 15, but was postponed to a later date that has not been finalized, according to court personnel.

He remains confined to Cumberland County Prison, with bail set at $750,000.

Sullenberger had over 20 years of experience with coaching and hitting lessons, according to the affidavit of probable cause from Carlisle Police. All of the incidents described in the affidavit had occurred in 2018.

In addition to his role with Central Penn Sportsplex, he had coached the Hummelstown-based Susquehanna Valley Slam travel girls fast-pitch softball team and had been hired in September 2018 as the head varsity girls softball coach for Carlisle High School. He was placed on leave by Carlisle Area School District in January and later fired.

Several youth sports organizations quickly distanced themselves from Central Penn Sportsplex in Carlisle, which was founded by Sullenberger and his daughter. The 25,000-square-foot sports complex was later sold and reopened under new ownership as Turf Time Athletics.

Send us your questions

Need an answer? We can help.

The Sentinel wants to know what you have always wanted to know.

Whether it’s politics, crime, history or just something you’ve always been curious about, if you have questions, The Sentinel will look for the answer and provide it in our online blog and as a weekly feature in the Sentinel print edition.

Shoot us an email at, call 240-7125 or stop by the office to submit your questions.

The best questions will be featured in weekly Ask/Answered columns online and in print.

Daniel Walmer covers public safety for The Sentinel. You can reach him by email at or by phone at 717-218-0021.


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News