You are the owner of this article.
Ask/Answered: Advanced Disposal won't take 'wish-cycling'

Ask/Answered: Advanced Disposal won't take 'wish-cycling'

Ask/Answered logo

Ask/Answered is a weekly feature for reader-submitted questions. Follow the blog online at

How often is Advanced Disposal not picking up residents’ recycling because the recyclables aren’t accepted by the company?

A spokesman for Advanced Disposal — which is responsible for collecting curbside recycling in Carlisle and a few other Cumberland County municipalities — did not have a statistical answer to that question.

There is reason to believe, however, that it isn’t an unusual occurrence.

Nationwide, about 30 percent of recycling volume is considered contaminated, according to Mark Nighbor, vice president of communications at Advanced Disposal. That includes items that, by their nature, can’t be recycled and items damaged by contact with contaminants (for example, food can destroy the structure of cardboard).

If an Advanced Disposal driver visually determines that a curbside recycling container is contaminated, he will not take any of the recycling in that container, according to Nighbor. Searching through a container for recyclable materials is considered a safety risk to the driver.

Recycling companies like Advanced Disposal are under increasing pressure from China, their main purchaser. China will not take recycling with more than a 0.05 percent contamination rate, and will ship it back to the United States if it doesn’t meet their threshold, Nighbor said.

The challenge is to convince residents not to engage in what Nighbor calls "wish-cycling:" placing items like pizza boxes, styrofoam containers or aerosol cans in recycling bins in the hope that they are recyclable. Ironically, those items can contaminate the rest of your recyclables and therefore reduce the amount of waste that is actually eliminated.

“If you’re in doubt, it is better environmentally for you to throw it out than to put it in the (recycling) container,” Nighbor said.

Send us your questions

Need an answer? We can help.

The Sentinel wants to know what you have always wanted to know.

Whether it’s politics, crime, history or just something you’ve always been curious about, if you have questions, The Sentinel will look for the answer and provide it in our online blog and as a weekly feature in the Sentinel print edition.

Shoot us an email at, call 240-7125 or stop by the office to submit your questions.

The best questions will be featured in weekly Ask/Answered columns online and in print.

Daniel Walmer covers public safety for The Sentinel. You can reach him by email at or by phone at 717-218-0021.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News