Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Political sign theft and vandalism in Cumberland County show growing political animosity, residents fear
alert featured
Election 2020

Political sign theft and vandalism in Cumberland County show growing political animosity, residents fear


On the eve of an election in a year when American partisanship has never been measurably higher, the nation’s heightened polarization can be seen, quite literally, in the yards of many Cumberland County homes and businesses.

By all accounts, the vandalism and theft of political signs has never been more intense than it has been in the run-up to the 2020 election, with local leaders from both parties citing a number of instances, and local police going out of their way to remind people to keep it civil.

“We have gone out of our way to issue a statement to tell people stop messing with the signs,” said Maurice Reeves, a local leader with the Cumberland County Democratic Committee.

Some of the vandalism isn’t just casual theft or defacement of small yard signs — a 4-by-8-foot sign that Reeves said he permanently anchored was destroyed last month.

“We put it in with two 6-foot metal fence posts and zip ties and they took it right off,” Reeves said.

Republican signs have befallen similar fates, with the Cumberland County Republican Committee frequently posting images of torn up or spray-painted Trump/Pence signs around the county.

“No candidate’s sign should be destroyed. We must show civility to one another during this election season,” the GOP committee wrote.

Petty vandalism by mischievous youths certainly accounts for a portion of political sign thefts and vandalism. But some people say that an increasing portion of the crimes are expressly political, and clearly not the work of errant teens.

Streets full of Biden/Harris signs in the Mechanicsburg and Upper Allen Township area had Trump bumper stickers affixed to them, according to Robin Agerton, an activist with the Upper Allen/Mechanicsburg Democratic Club.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

Agerton’s own signs at her home in Mechanicsburg borough were spray-painted over or stolen multiple times until she affixed them to her porch. She said her neighbors trained security cameras on their Biden/Harris sign with the warning “smile, you’re on camera” written on it.

Reeves said he and several others he knows have done the same.

“I think if the camera weren’t there, they probably would’ve been gone by now,” Reeves said of his signs.

“I don’t believe this is kids,” Agerton said. “My only concern is that it escalates. Our police shouldn’t have to be dealing with this.”

However, they are. Police agencies across the county have posted reports and requests for public assistance in sign thefts, although it would appear few if any are solved.

“It’s a pain for them to take these calls all the time, but they want us to keep calling them, just to document it,” Agerton said.

In June, someone stole a 6-by-12-foot Trump sign from Wilson Street in Carlisle. Valued at $90, it was not immediately recovered, Carlisle Borough police reported.

In September, Camp Hill Borough police issued a blanket reminder, in light of allegedly rampant sign theft, that “every citizen has the right to place political signs of their choice in their yard” under the First Amendment of U.S. Constitution.

“I think what we’re seeing on social media and on the news is playing out in our communities,” Agerton said. “I think the partisanship at the presidential level is trickling down.”

Polling indicates that that is the case in the United States, and has been growing for some time. Pew Research polling conducted in September 2019 found that 55% of Republicans and 47% of Democrats believed members of the opposite party were “more immoral” than the average American, versus 47% and 35% of respondents, respectively, three years earlier.

Likewise, 63% of Republicans see their Democratic neighbors as “more unpatriotic” than the baseline American; 75% of Democrats see Republicans as “more close-minded,” according to Pew data.

These feelings are not confined to the realm of politics. Pew data shows only 45% of Democrats and 38% of Republicans agree that members of the opposing party share other values and goals, even if they disagree about politics, with a majority of Americans now feeling that they lack common ground with their political opponents even outside the realm of electoral politics.

Primary Preview 2020: A look at contested races on June 2

Check out our preview of contested races in this year's primary on June 2.

In this June 2019 file photo, a paper ballot is shown during a demonstration of the ExpressVote XL voting machine at the Reading Terminal Mark…

Email Zack at


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News