Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Election 2021: Cumberland County faces open positions for sheriff, court of common pleas judge
Cumberland County

Election 2021: Cumberland County faces open positions for sheriff, court of common pleas judge


Cumberland County’s 2021 local election will have two fully open positions for the county sheriff and a court of common pleas judge, while the remainder of the county’s’ elected administrative positions — known as row offices — appear to have an incumbent running for re-election, according to the county’s Republican committee.

The 2021 ballot will also have a number of municipal seats up for grabs, where Democrats are more likely to notch gains in some of the county’s bluer boroughs.

County Sheriff Ronny Anderson is retiring, and Chief Deputy Jody Smith has already announced a run to succeed him. Court of Common Pleas Judge Thomas Placey is not seeking retention, according to state court records, meaning his seat will be open to a multicandidate ballot.

Pennsylvania judges can keep their seats by facing a yes-or-no retention question every 10 years, but Placey — who is facing accusations of erratic behavior in the Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline — has not filed to be retained.

Court of Common Pleas Judge Christylee Peck is seeking retention, according to state records.

GOP incumbents for the remaining row offices have already been endorsed by the Cumberland County Republican Committee. They include Clerk of Courts Denny Lebo, Controller Al Whitcomb, Coroner Charley Hall, Prothonotary Dale Sabadish, Recorder of Deeds Tammy Shearer, and Register of Wills Lisa Grayson.

Anderson, who first won election in 2009, said he was confident in his staff’s ability to keep things moving forward without him at the helm.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

“I was just looking over some of my retirement papers, and it’ll be 44 years at the end of this year,” said Anderson, who started his career in county law enforcement in 1977.

“It’s definitely bittersweet,” he said. “I’m going to miss the people, I’m going to miss the public.”

Four judicial candidates have sought the endorsement of the county GOP committee to run for the open common pleas judgeship, according to Chairman Lou Capozzi — current Magisterial District Judge Kathy Silcox, current county Chief Deputy District Attorney Michelle Sibert, Widener Law Professor Michael Dimino, and local attorney Paul Edger.

No candidate reached the committee’s 60% vote threshold for endorsement, Capozzi said, so the county GOP has not made an official pick for the open judge’s seat.

Countywide row offices offer a significant edge to Republicans in the general election, given the GOP’s overall registration advantage in Cumberland County. That isn’t the case, however, for municipal races in some of the county’s Democratic-leaning boroughs; Carlisle and Camp Hill are solidly blue, and places like Mechanicsburg and New Cumberland have seen increasingly better ballot performance from Democrats.

The Cumberland County Democratic Committee expects to have full slates of candidates for competitive races in places like New Cumberland and East Pennsboro Township, committee spokesperson Colleen Nguyen said.

“Our numbers for these municipal offices are probably a little higher than normal,” due to strong interest from potential candidates, Nguyen said.

Party nomination petitions must be filed by March 9 for the 2021 primary, which will be held May 18. The 2021 general election is Nov. 2.

Email Zack at


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News